Greylisting
So one of my clients showed me some rejected mail she got when trying to send to a user whom she knew she had the right email address for.
The return mail was a “451 4.7.1 message delayed” error and had a link for http://greylisting.org. So I went to check it out thinking we were on some sort of deny list (IE, a blacklist).
Turns out, greylisting.org’s policy is to deay/block ALL incomming mail the first time from any source. They rely on the user trying a second time to allow the message through … I’m not making this up:
What happen is that each time a given mailbox receives an email from an unknown contact (ip), that mail is rejected with a “try again later”-message (This happens at the SMTP layer and is transparent to the end user). This, in the short run, means that all mail gets delayed at least until the sender tries again.
What the fuck? This is ludacris. If things keep going this direction then SMTP is due to become a proverbial paperweight, and we’ll go back to the days of faxes and carrier pidgens.
Furthermore, whoever came up with his “greylist” idea needs to be drug out into the street, shot in each join and told to walk to a hospital, where they’ll be rejected the first time and have to try again later.
May God have mercy on the soul of the internet.

